The Rev. J. H. Pinder (1830-1835)
The Rev. Henry Jones (1835-1486)
The Rev. Richard Rawle (1847-1864)
The Rev. W. T. Webb (1864-1884)
The Rev. A. Caldecott (1884-1885)
The Rev. Herbert Bindley (1890-1910)
The Rev. Arthur Anstey (1910-1918)
The Rev. Canon John C. Wippell (1918-1945)
The Rev. A. H. Sayer (1945-1955)
The Rev. Jonathan Graham, C.R. (1955-1957)
The Rev. Anselm Genders, C.R. (1957-1965)
The Rev. William Wheeldon, C.R. (1965-1966)
The Rev. Godfrey Pawson, C.R. (1966-1969)
The Rev. Martin Garrison (1969-1970)
The Rev. Dr. Kortright Davis (1970-1971
(Acting))
The Rev. Dr. Sehon Goodridge (1971-1982)
Prof. Canon Noel F. Titus (1983-2004)
The Rev. Dr. Ian Rock (2004-2006 (Acting))
The Rev. Dr. Ian Rock (2006- 2015)
Adapted from Holder, John W., Codrington College: A Brief History, Barbados: Caribbean Contact, 1988.